Underkeep delivers a cheerful, modern interpretation of the classic first-person dungeon crawler, with four-character parties, tile-based exploration, dangerous monsters and plenty of old-school surprises. It is available now on Steam.
Its design is especially reminiscent of 1987’s Dungeon Master, while the outdoor areas bring to mind 1993’s Dungeon Master II: The Legend of Skullkeep. Players who came to the format through Legend of Grimrock will also find the structure immediately familiar. This is a traditional “blobber”: the whole party moves as one unit rather than as separate characters.
That makes Underkeep a welcome return to a format shaped by games such as Wizardry, Eye of the Beholder and Dungeon Master. It is not without some awkward systems, but its combination of exploration, party-building and turn-based combat makes it remarkably satisfying.

Build a party and plan every turn
At the beginning, you create four heroes by combining races and classes, choosing profile pictures and deciding how the group will work together. The adventure then begins in the woods, with the Village of Underkeep as your first major destination. Monsters, dungeons and environmental puzzles stand between the party and that goal.
Party composition matters. A durable fighter can hold the front line while rangers and spellcasters operate from behind, and each character takes a turn choosing an attack or another action. Basic strikes, arrow attacks and more specialised abilities all compete for your attention as the group develops.
Combat is less about sidestepping attacks than making good decisions before the action begins. Characters cannot move around during a turn, so you must choose the order of the four party members’ actions. Only after everyone has acted can the group move to another tile, at which point enemies get their opportunity to respond.
For readers interested in how classic controls and hardware translate to a home setup, RETROCADE’s arcade machine buying guide offers useful context.
A world that rewards wandering
Reaching Underkeep opens up the game considerably. The settlement contains several shops, characters to meet and quests to accept, while the surrounding regions can be approached in multiple directions. The result is a pleasingly open adventure built around filling in the map, finding side dungeons and investigating small puzzles that can lead to useful equipment.
The freedom also creates one of the game’s biggest frustrations: difficulty changes sharply between areas. Travelling north towards Caerlin Woods can end with a brutal encounter against griffins before the party is ready. Heading south to the Cemetery may seem safer, only for another difficult fight to halt your progress.
There is no clear indication of which areas are suitable for the party’s current strength, leaving you to discover the correct route through trial and error. That can be irritating, but returning later with improved weapons and a few extra levels is genuinely rewarding. Enemies that once defeated the group with ease can eventually be overcome through better preparation.

Death, rest and character development
Reviving fallen heroes is considerably more convenient than in Dungeon Master. Each region contains a statue that can restore a dead character in exchange for gold, although the revived hero returns with only a single point of health. Healing potions can be found or crafted, while resting is the more common way to restore health, stamina and mana.
Resting has its own complications. The party needs food, and a single recovery period can consume tens of meals. Food is expensive to stockpile, and the amount used is not always predictable. Rest also cannot be interrupted partway through, so it would be helpful to see the expected cost before committing and to choose when the party wakes.
The spell system could be more distinctive; a rune-based approach, for example, might have added another layer of character identity. Even so, levelling presents a useful selection of abilities, and skills can be changed during play. Level-ups are infrequent and there is no respec option, so deciding whether to specialise in one or two skills or spread the investment across several becomes an important choice.
Those considering a physical arcade setup can browse RETROCADE’s arcade machines, while hands-on builders may prefer the flexibility of DIY arcade kits.
A simple adventure with plenty of character
Underkeep includes more story than is typical for this style of dungeon crawler. Characters encountered in the world have a clear interest in the unfolding events, including a quest involving missing dwarfs and their dispute over how to deal with an enraged dragon. The writing is not especially complex, but it gives the exploration a welcome sense of purpose without overwhelming the core adventure.
Race and class choices also influence events outside combat. An Elk ranger can identify danger in the woods, while a Raven wizard can detect unusual magical activity. One side quest can even result in every party member occasionally transforming into a mushroom. The effect does not appear to cause any serious problems, but it is a memorable consequence of the group’s decisions.
Visually, the game is appealing, with distinctive enemy designs and an excellent soundtrack. It is neither as punishing as Wizardry nor as lore-heavy as Might & Magic. Instead, it pursues a simpler, more focused version of the genre—one that still leaves room for exploration, tactical choices and the pleasure of returning to a place that once defeated you.
Underkeep proves that a straightforward dungeon crawler can still feel fresh. Its difficulty signposting and resting system could be clearer, but the combination of party-building, open-ended exploration, environmental puzzles, quests and satisfying progression makes it an enjoyable modern take on a classic style.



Leave a Reply