Torchic Star card auction could set a Pokémon TCG record

A rare 2004 Torchic Star card has become the focus of a controversial Pokémon TCG auction, with bidding reaching $1.3 million despite visible condition issues.

For collectors spending millions, the definition of “pristine” matters. A card may look excellent to a casual fan while falling short of the standards expected from a top-tier professional grade.

Why a PSA 10 grade matters

PSA describes a Gem Mint 10 card as virtually perfect. It should have sharp corners, clean printing, undamaged gloss, no stains and strong overall centring. A slight printing imperfection may be accepted, but obvious flaws are generally inconsistent with the grade.

That makes the Torchic Star especially divisive. The card comes from the 2004 EX Team Rocket Returns set, which had a small print run, and its low pull rate makes surviving copies scarce.

A scarce card with an extraordinary valuation

Only 30 ungraded copies are currently listed for sale. None of those copies is graded PSA 10, while even an ungraded example sells for at least a few thousand dollars. Professionally graded copies command substantially more.

In February 2026, a Torchic Star owned by Steve Aoki sold for $117,800. That card received a CGC grade of 10, making it one of the most expensive Pokémon card sales ever recorded at the time.

The current auction is on another level. Its PSA 10 Torchic Star has reached $1.3 million, with eight days remaining when the sale was reported. As with any auction, the final result could still change, and there is always a possibility that a winning bidder fails to complete payment.

If the transaction is completed at that figure, the card would become the second-highest Pokémon TCG sale ever made. It would sit behind Logan Paul’s $16.4 million Pikachu Illustrator card.

The condition dispute

From the front, the card appears impressive. However, the reverse reveals the details driving the debate.

White spots can be seen along the right side at the top, centre and bottom. The left edges also show noticeable fraying.

Those defects might trigger arguments over terms such as “lightly played” and “near mint” in an ordinary sale. Rarity and age also lead many collectors to judge the card more generously. The central question is whether its condition justifies a record-level price of $1.3 million or more.

How collectors are responding

Reaction from the TCG community has been sharply divided. One Pokémon fan wrote on Facebook that the sale was “insane”, while another suggested the card would be closer to a PSA 7 if it were graded again.

A collector on Reddit questioned the logic behind the valuation and expressed disbelief at the sums being paid.

Why the grade may be under scrutiny

One possible explanation is timing. The card may have received its PSA certification before the current surge of interest and money in Pokémon collecting. With grading demand higher than ever and a substantial backlog, collectors argue that modern grading standards are harder to satisfy.

Visible defects that might once have escaped notice are now less likely to receive a PSA 10, unless the flaw is treated as an acceptable printing imperfection. That creates a striking contrast between an older grade and today’s expectations.

There are estimated to be just 19 PSA 10 Torchic Star cards in existence, and almost all are privately held or financially inaccessible. Supporters of the auction therefore see the price as a predictable consequence of one of the rarest Gold Star cards becoming publicly available.

For more collecting and gaming coverage, browse the RETROCADE arcade blog, or explore the arcade machine buying guide for advice on choosing a home cabinet. Collectors planning a dedicated games room can also compare compact bartop arcades and virtual pinball machines.