RETROCADE RETROCADE
0
RETROCADE arcade machines, virtual pinball, racing simulator and parts banner

After years of starting and stopping Dark Souls, I have finally reached further than ever before. Two days ago, following repeated attempts and a detour to the sewers to farm rats for Humanity, I defeated Ornstein and Smough—and the unpleasant guards outside their arena. That victory opened the way to what I understand is the game’s second half.

Before leaving the first act behind, however, I found a room above the boss arena. Warm golden light spilled into the corridor, while player messages covered the floor. Most of them mentioned a chest. The chamber itself contained a huge woman reclining on a raised platform, calmly watching my approach. When I came close, the game offered one command: Kneel.

Gwynevere

This was Gwynevere, Princess of Sunlight, apparently waiting to reward the Chosen Undead. I had been sent to claim the Lordvessel and help begin a new Age of Fire—or something along those lines. Gwynevere handed over the vessel, praised my progress and sent me onwards with an almost suspicious amount of encouragement. A grand, triumphant musical score completed the presentation.

It was lovely. It was uplifting. It was also completely wrong.

Why did the room feel as though it stank?

I have never completed Dark Souls, so much of its wider story has reached me indirectly. I know there is an important choice near the end. I have seen pieces of battles involving the Four Kings and Seath the Scaleless. I know Solaire may die, and that there is apparently a way to save him, though I have no idea how. Gwynevere and Anor Londo, however, remain largely unexplained territory.

My expectations have been shaped by hours with Elden Ring and Elden Ring: Nightreign, along with some time in King’s Field 4. Those games taught me that in FromSoftware’s worlds, excessive cheerfulness is rarely innocent. A glowing princess with an extravagant welcome does not belong in a game otherwise defined by oppressive spaces, harsh sound effects, Firelink Shrine and the shrieks of boss encounters.

Everything about the scene felt staged. I could not explain the suspicion, but I could not shake it either.

Then I noticed one message among the jokes about Gwynevere’s appearance:

Try attacking.

That suggestion has occupied my thoughts for two days.

I almost never kill friendly non-player characters deliberately. Across every game I have played, the list of innocent NPCs I have murdered would fit on one hand—unless Everhood counts. I once attempted a genocide run in Undertale and abandoned it after three battles. In Elden Ring, accidentally hitting the Turtle Pope was enough to make me immediately quit and reload. I can accept the occasional morally questionable decision, but choosing murder is another matter.

So why was I seriously considering shooting a sun goddess?

Dark Souls explains very little directly. Its history and motivations are scattered across brief conversations, environmental details and item descriptions. I am not a dedicated lore hunter, and I have not studied Anor Londo closely enough to understand its purpose or its secrets. At this point, I have generally trusted the instructions given to me. Ring the bells, and a route opens. Retrieve the Lordvessel, and the next objective becomes clear. The enemies I have been asked to defeat have mostly appeared thoroughly unpleasant. The people giving me guidance, meanwhile, have been unusually kind in a world where kindness is scarce.

Solaire worships the sun. Surely the Sunlight Princess must be trustworthy.

Surely.

Unable to settle the question, I delayed. I returned to the Undead Asylum and fell through the floor. I spent time inside a painting, where I offered mercy to a woman in white who insisted that the inhabitants of her world were good and gentle, despite the apparent violence happening outside. Still, it felt as though an unseen deadline was approaching.

I wanted to decide whether I trusted the path laid out before me before venturing onwards to gather the great souls needed for the Lordvessel. Games that create this kind of uncertainty are among my favourites. They put pressure on the player without offering a clean answer, then leave the consequences in our hands.

That is something I recognise from Elden Ring: FromSoftware is comfortable presenting decisions without an obvious moral solution. I want to save Solaire, but I do not want a guide to tell me how. I want to discover what happens to Siegmeyer, even if failing to find him becomes part of my own playthrough. The game continues, and a flawless run is impossible.

I have been following other arcade and gaming stories between sessions, but this is the sort of dilemma that makes me put the controller down and think. I could avoid attacking Gwynevere and preserve the apparent kindness of the scene. On the other hand, refusing to act would mean missing whatever strange consequence the game had prepared.

Perhaps nothing would happen. Perhaps she is a god, or immortal, or protected from ordinary weapons. Perhaps firing at her would be a meaningless mistake.

Or perhaps the entire presentation was a trap.

After enough hesitation, I made my decision.

I was going to shoot her.

Gwyndolin2
Dark Anor Londo

Oh.

Oh, absolutely.

That sudden discovery is exactly why games like Dark Souls work so well. Whether you are playing on a full arcade machine, exploring older games through a compact bartop cabinet or simply returning to a classic at home, the best interactive moments are often the ones that make you question your own instincts.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *