
A remake with a strong GOTY case
Since The Game Awards began in 2014, several highly praised remakes have missed out on a Game of the Year nomination. Shadow of the Colossus, The Legend of Zelda: Link’s Awakening, Demon’s Souls, The Last of Us Part 1 and Silent Hill 2 were all among their respective years’ best-reviewed games, yet none reached the category.
Only four remakes have been nominated so far: Resident Evil 2, Resident Evil 4, Final Fantasy 7 Remake and Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth. Their common feature is not simple technical improvement. Each reinterprets its source material through a modern design language, with major changes to structure, presentation or even genre. The Final Fantasy 7 project, for example, expands one original game into a three-part experience.

Nintendo’s new version of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time occupies an interesting middle ground. It remains closely tied to the original story and design, while introducing thoughtful modern updates and an exceptionally ambitious visual overhaul.
It is not a total reinvention in the manner of Capcom’s Resident Evil remakes or Square Enix’s Final Fantasy 7 project. Nor is it a meticulous reconstruction such as Bluepoint’s PlayStation 4 edition of Shadow of the Colossus. Instead, it deliberately allows the classic to look and feel noticeably different.
Why a nomination looks likely

Outstanding critical reception
The clearest argument is its critical response. With a Metacritic score of 96, Ocarina of Time is currently the year’s highest-rated game. Other major contenders, including Resident Evil Requiem and Fire Emblem: Fortune’s Weave, have not reached the 90s. The only unreleased title identified as a possible challenger is Grand Theft Auto 6.
That level of acclaim makes the remake impossible to overlook when awards discussions begin. Readers following more arcade and gaming news will recognise the pattern: exceptional reviews can force an established property into a conversation usually dominated by new releases.
A landmark original

The 1998 Ocarina of Time also has an unusually powerful reputation among critics and jurors. Its standing goes beyond ordinary fondness for an older game. It is widely regarded as one of the medium’s defining masterpieces, with only a small number of titles, including Final Fantasy 7, occupying a similar position.
That gives the remake two advantages at once: it can appeal to memories of an influential classic, while also demonstrating that the new version has treated its source with care. If the jury believes Nintendo has done justice to that legacy, recognition is likely.
It feels like a major release

Many remakes are important to established fans but do not feel like the central event of their release year. Ocarina of Time appears to have crossed that line. Its dramatic visual transformation, arriving decades after the original, gives it the impact of a major contemporary launch.
Nintendo’s internal Zelda team handled the project rather than an outside studio, and the company has presented it as the year’s biggest game. Public discussion has positioned it as one of the few releases capable of standing alongside GTA 6, making it a prominent game of the moment.
The categories it could enter

A Game of the Year nomination looks highly probable, with several additional categories also within reach. Best Action/Adventure, Best Score and Music, Best Audio Design and Best Art Direction are all plausible possibilities.
The art direction is particularly difficult to ignore. Although the remake’s visual approach initially divided opinion, many critics have since embraced its distinct identity. Whatever view one takes of the changes, they reflect a clear artistic vision executed with considerable skill. For anyone considering a home setup for classic and modern gaming, the arcade machine collection offers another way to celebrate influential game design.
Why winning is a different question

A nomination and a victory are not the same thing. The argument against a win is not that the remake lacks quality; it is that it remains a remake. Apart from the Final Fantasy 7 games, which are structurally close to new releases, it is difficult to imagine an updated version of an existing work taking the industry’s highest prize.
Ocarina of Time may be accepted as one of the year’s best games, but crowning it as the single best game could suggest that the medium’s strongest current achievement is a return to an older design rather than a new creative statement.
A nomination would recognise the classic’s continuing influence and Nintendo’s execution. A win would make a broader claim about where game design is heading.



The likely outcome
Ocarina of Time has the reviews, cultural importance, visibility and production ambition to secure a Game of the Year nomination. It may also collect nominations for action-adventure, music, audio and art direction.
Winning, however, seems far less likely. Even without GTA 6 in the field, the remake’s status as a reconstruction of an existing masterpiece would probably work against it. Recognising its success is sensible; declaring it the medium’s finest current work would carry a much more complicated message.
For more perspective on choosing hardware for older favourites and modern releases, see RETROCADE’s arcade machine buying guide and explore compact options in the bartop arcade range.


Leave a Reply