Every GTA game ranked by Metacritic score
With the next chapter in Rockstar’s open-world crime series approaching, it is a good time to revisit the critical history of Grand Theft Auto. Across its many releases, the series has produced several games with scores in the high 90s, alongside a handful of more uneven experiments.


This ranking covers the ten GTA games with Metacritic scores, using each title’s original release platform. Expansions such as The Ballad of Gay Tony, GTA Online, ports and the first three releases—Grand Theft Auto, GTA London 1969 and GTA London 1961—are excluded. Those early games do not have enough reviews for a Metacritic score, while GTA Online is an evolving service rather than a conventionally reviewed release. Where scores are tied, the game with more reviews takes the higher position.
For more gaming history and hardware discussion, explore the RETROCADE Arcade Blog or browse the arcade machine collection.
10. GTA Advance (2004)

Metacritic score: 68
Platform: Game Boy Advance
GTA Advance is a top-down prequel to GTA 3 set in Liberty City, not a remake of the original game. Critics felt its compact presentation did not match the series’ newer direction. It included street races, firefighting, vigilante missions and other familiar activities, but its rougher handling, smaller world and weaker radio stations made it feel like an important experiment rather than a polished successor.
9. Grand Theft Auto 2 (1999)

Metacritic score: 70
Platforms: PC, PlayStation 2
This top-down sequel expanded the formula with a more complex mission structure, new weapons, a livelier city, a new soundtrack and an early faction-loyalty system. Reviewers nevertheless viewed it as too close to the first game, with awkward controls and familiar gameplay holding it back. Its future as a global entertainment phenomenon was far from obvious at this stage.
8. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories (2006)

Metacritic score: 86
Platform: PSP
Set in early-1980s Vice City, this prequel follows former soldier Vic Vance as he builds a criminal empire with his brother Lance. Critics liked the empire-building mechanics and the substantial overall package, although some felt the core GTA structure was beginning to show its age. Repeated complaints about familiar flaws did not outweigh the game’s ambition.
7. Grand Theft Auto: Liberty City Stories (2005)

Metacritic score: 88
Platform: PSP
Toni Cipriani, a supporting character from GTA 3, takes centre stage as he climbs through the Leone crime family while rival Mafia organisations battle for control. The PSP release was praised as a remarkable technical achievement, bringing a substantial open-world experience to a handheld. Its weaker storyline and basic mission design were counterbalanced by plentiful optional activities and a city that remained enjoyable to explore after the main story.
6. Grand Theft Auto: Chinatown Wars (2009)

Metacritic score: 93
Platform: Nintendo DS
Chinatown Wars combines the series’ original top-down viewpoint with its later open-world systems. Huang Lee travels to Liberty City to recover a sword entrusted to him by his late father, becoming caught in a conflict between the Triads. Critics praised its focus on chases, missions and mayhem, while its use of Nintendo DS controls and features made it feel like more than a scaled-down port.
5. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City (2002)

Metacritic score: 95
Platform: PlayStation 2
Tommy Vercetti’s rise through a neon-soaked, Miami-inspired underworld made Vice City one of the defining PlayStation 2 games. Its richer world, open-ended play, memorable soundtrack and 1980s setting impressed critics, even as controls and mission design remained recurring weak points. The game’s atmosphere helped establish Vice City as one of Rockstar’s most enduring locations.
4. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas (2004)

Metacritic score: 95
Platform: PlayStation 2
Carl “CJ” Johnson returns home after his mother’s murder and works to restore his gang’s influence. San Andreas expanded the series with a huge setting, multiple cities and a broad range of activities, earning exceptional reviews for its scale and variety. One dissenting view argued that the open world still limited players to prescribed objectives, but most critics regarded it as an outstanding all-round entertainment package.
3. Grand Theft Auto 3 (2001)

Metacritic score: 97
Platform: PlayStation 2
GTA 3 transformed the series by moving its crime sandbox into a fully 3D Liberty City. Silent protagonist Claude pursues revenge against his former girlfriend while becoming entangled in the city’s criminal underworld. Its scale, freedom and detailed world helped establish the modern open-world template, while critics praised it as one of the PlayStation 2’s defining experiences.
2. Grand Theft Auto 5 (2013)

Metacritic score: 97
Platforms: PlayStation 3, Xbox 360
Set in the Los Angeles-inspired region of San Andreas, GTA 5 follows Michael, Franklin and Trevor through a story built around three playable perspectives. Critics welcomed the refined mission design, ambitious world and sharp satire, and the game became only the second title to receive a perfect score from Famitsu, after The Elder Scrolls 5: Skyrim.
Its treatment of torture and women also drew serious criticism. Some reviewers considered the game’s portrayal of women particularly weak, an issue that remains part of the wider discussion surrounding Rockstar’s writing.

1. Grand Theft Auto 4 (2008)

Metacritic score: 98
Platforms: PlayStation 3, Xbox 360
Niko Bellic arrives in Liberty City hoping to pursue the American Dream after hearing extravagant stories from his cousin Roman. Instead, he finds debt, organised crime and a life that becomes increasingly difficult to escape. The New York-inspired city was widely celebrated for its scale, seamless interiors and detailed design, while Niko’s darker, more personal story gave the game a distinctive tone.
The result was the highest-scoring GTA release in this ranking. Its emphasis on character, consequence and atmosphere gave it an edge over the more expansive but equally acclaimed games that followed.

What the scores reveal
The ranking shows how consistently Rockstar refined the same basic idea. The early top-down games established the criminal sandbox, GTA 3 made it three-dimensional, and later entries expanded the world, tone and number of things to do. Even the lower-ranked releases contributed useful ideas, from handheld open-world design to empire building and faction systems.
For more retro-focused setups, compare the options in the Arcade Machine Buying Guide, consider a compact bartop arcade, or browse arcade parts and controls for a custom project.





Leave a Reply