The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3 has larger stakes, striking set pieces and several strong character moments, but its constant callbacks to Peter Jackson’s trilogy make the prequel feel more derivative than epic.


Prime Video’s series is set thousands of years before the familiar events of Middle-earth, during Tolkien’s Second Age. After two seasons spent establishing Sauron, played by Charlie Vickers, the story moves forward with a five-year time jump and a renewed focus on the One Ring.
That shift brings the show closer to the mythology audiences know from the films. Unfortunately, the resemblance often feels deliberate rather than natural. Galadriel, played by Morfydd Clark, and Arondir, played by Ismael Cruz Córdova, enter enemy territory with an untrustworthy guide who dislikes Elven food and attempts to turn them against one another. Galadriel later hides from a Nazgnagôl, an early form of the Ringwraiths, while another scene treats “fellowship” as an almost literal slogan of hope.
These moments echo familiar scenes involving Gollum, Frodo, Sam and the Fellowship. Instead of giving the prequel its own identity, they underline how difficult it is for the series to escape the shadow of a much-loved film trilogy. Viewers looking for more fantasy entertainment can browse RETROCADE’s arcade blog or explore the latest arcade videos between episodes.
Big set pieces, uneven storytelling

Season 3 is at its best when it commits to spectacle and character drama. Sauron is closer than ever to controlling Middle-earth, distributing the nine rings intended for mortal men after obtaining them from Celebrimbor at the end of season 2. His increasingly powerful lieutenants give the conflict a sharper sense of danger.
The ongoing crisis in Khazad-dûm remains one of the show’s strongest threads. Durin IV, played by Owain Arthur, and Disa, played by Sophia Nomvete, try to protect their kingdom from Durin’s older brother Thráin, played by Eddie Marsan. The rogue Orc Marnûkh, played by Adam Young, is clearly designed as a Gollum-like figure, but his humour and unpredictability make him surprisingly effective. Sauron’s conversation with the Balrog, portrayed by an unrecognisable Simon Pegg, is among the season’s most dramatic sequences.
Other storylines do not land with the same force. Gandalf spent the previous two seasons with the Harfoots, yet they are absent from the first seven episodes of this season. Their removal makes that earlier detour feel less meaningful and leaves the new episodes noticeably darker and less playful.










Gandalf instead spends much of the season exploring the complicated nature of Tolkien’s Istari and deciding how he fits into the war. His conflict with the Dark Wizard, played by Ciarán Hinds, remains underwhelming because the character feels like a diluted version of Saruman rather than a memorable threat.
The series also struggles with its prequel premise. Because viewers already know the broad shape of Middle-earth’s future, the show must make its journey compelling even when its destination is fixed. At times it approaches that challenge successfully, particularly through the tragedies surrounding Durin III and Celebrimbor. Elsewhere, it resembles an origin-story machine, explaining the beginnings of details such as the plans for Lothlórien and Gandalf’s hat.
Númenor remains the weakest link
Númenor looks magnificent, with carefully designed costumes and elaborate sets, but its political conflict remains shallow. The struggle between the new king Pharazôn, played by Trystan Gravelle, and the deposed queen Míriel, played by Cynthia Addai-Robinson, borrows the surface of prestige fantasy without developing enough depth underneath.
Elrond, played by Robert Aramayo, has an important connection to Númenor because the island kingdom was founded by his brother. However, he has far more convincing chemistry with Durin than with the Númenórean characters. Even Gil-galad, played by Benjamin Walker, seems to share the audience’s impatience with the political detour.
For readers inspired by fantasy worlds and hands-on gaming, RETROCADE’s arcade machines offer a more tangible way to bring entertainment home. Those planning a custom project can also compare DIY arcade kits and arcade and pinball plans.
A prequel with occasional magic
The third season shares a central weakness with its predecessors: it can be impressive, moving and frustrating within the same episode. Its strongest sequences show why Middle-earth still has enormous dramatic potential. Its weaker passages reveal a production searching for significance by repeating familiar ideas and expanding side stories that do not earn their place.
The Rings of Power is unlikely to redefine fantasy television in the way Jackson’s films did. It can, however, provide intermittent glimpses of that world’s grandeur. For viewers who want more time in Middle-earth, those glimpses may be enough, provided they are willing to accept the uneven journey.




The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3 premieres on November 11 on Prime Video.


Leave a Reply