Rings of Power season 3 gives an Orc a moral choice

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power is preparing for a major shift in its third season. The story will jump forward five years, and co-showrunner Patrick McKay has described the new direction as something of a “soft reboot”. More significantly, the series will introduce an Orc who stands against Sauron.

That character is Marnûkh, an Orc who claims to have deserted Sauron’s forces. He tells the Elves that he can reveal details of Sauron’s plans, including the attempt to forge the One Ring. Marnûkh believes the Ring would ultimately enslave everyone, Orcs included, and prevent another rebellion like the one led by Adar, who died in the previous season.

Director Sanaa Hamri has said she has a particular affection for Marnûkh and expects viewers to feel conflicted about him. His arrival gives the series an opportunity to explore an Orc as an individual with motives, fears and the capacity to make a difficult choice.

Why Marnûkh matters to Tolkien’s mythology

In most traditional portrayals of Middle-earth, Orcs are presented as brutal servants of evil. They can speak and reason, yet the stories rarely allow them to demonstrate genuine moral independence. Season 3 will challenge that pattern by placing an Orc on the side of the protagonists.

This is not the series’ first attempt to complicate Orc society. The previous season briefly showed an Orc with a family, while Adar was presented as an Elf corrupted by Morgoth into one of the first Orcs. Despite that origin, Adar opposed Sauron.

Tolkien’s unresolved Orc dilemma

The question of Orc morality troubled J.R.R. Tolkien. He described The Lord of the Rings as a fundamentally religious and Catholic work, which made the issue of Orcs especially difficult. If Orcs could speak, think and choose, they appeared to possess the qualities that make moral responsibility possible. Yet Tolkien’s stories generally treated them as inherently evil and disposable in battle.

He considered several explanations for their existence. Orcs might have been created directly by Morgoth as evil beings, reduced to something closer to beasts, or transformed from Elves. Tolkien never settled comfortably on one account, leaving the question of their souls and free will unresolved.

Later fantasy games have faced a similar problem. Shadow of Mordor, for example, gave Orcs distinctive personalities while asking players to kill them and control their minds. The tension between recognisable individuality and dehumanisation has also prompted comparisons with real-world racism, a concern discussed by Tolkien scholar Robert T. Tally.

What season 3 could change

Marnûkh’s story will test whether the series can treat Orcs as people with competing loyalties rather than a single, uniformly evil faction. It also connects the show’s larger conflict over the One Ring with a rebellion from within Sauron’s own army.

The approach will be closely watched because portrayals of morally complex villains can reshape an entire fantasy world. For readers and players who enjoy stories built around branching allegiances, the idea may feel familiar; for Tolkien fans, it directly engages with a problem the author never fully solved.

Season 3 of The Rings of Power is scheduled to debut on Prime Video on 11 November. Australian viewers will find more entertainment and gaming coverage in the RETROCADE Arcade Blog, including features for fantasy fans looking to bring themed gaming into a games room.

For a compact setup, a bartop arcade can add dedicated play without taking over a room, while larger collections can be explored through RETROCADE’s arcade machines range.