RETROCADE RETROCADE
0
RETROCADE arcade machines, virtual pinball, racing simulator and parts banner

In 2020, the games industry publicly aligned itself with Black Lives Matter as protests spread across North America and beyond after the police killings of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor. Publishers issued statements, announced donations and promised to improve representation. Six years later, much of that visible commitment has faded.

This is not simply a story about corporate messaging. The North American games sector reflects the social, economic and political systems around it. Conversations with Black developers, writers, artists and industry organisers reveal an industry where representation briefly became a priority, then collided with layoffs, studio closures, political pressure and an entrenched lack of material support.

For Australian players and arcade enthusiasts, the lesson reaches beyond blockbuster releases. Every game, from a home arcade machine to a major console production, is shaped by the people and conditions behind it.

Gdc Report

The promises made in 2020

During the racial justice protests, Ubisoft said it would donate US$100,000 to the NAACP and Black Lives Matter. Square Enix announced a US$250,000 contribution to Black Lives Matter and other charities. EA also pledged US$1 million to organisations including the Equal Justice Initiative and the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, on a webpage that has since been removed.

The donations could provide useful support, but they also attracted criticism because many appeared to function as public relations as much as long-term reform. In Laundering Black Rage, Too Black and Dr Rasul A. Mowatt question how corporate marketing converted anger over police violence into a safe, commercial message.

Former EA and Respawn narrative designer Jarory De Jesus believes the removal of EA’s pledge was connected to the changing political environment. He argues that the industry’s movement from openly supporting diversity towards supposedly “neutral” language was not neutral at all. The United States has since faced restrictions and threats aimed at diversity, equity and inclusion programmes, while the Supreme Court effectively ended affirmative action in 2023 and a wave of anti-trans laws created further pressure.

De Jesus contrasts EA’s later silence with his experience at Scopely in 2020. That company told employees it had set aside US$1 million to support staff facing legal problems because of protest activity, and employees were supported if they wished to attend demonstrations. At Respawn, he also saw constructive work through a diversity, equity and inclusion board while the Apex Legends team developed the trans hero Catalyst.

Those examples did not last across the sector. Nearly everyone consulted for this account said that serious initiatives launched during 2020 had been reduced or closed by roughly three years later.

When solidarity becomes a transaction

Catt Small, executive director of Game Devs of Color, Inc, welcomed the funding that arrived in 2020 because it could be passed to people who needed it. At the same time, she suspected that much of the support was tied to a temporary public moment rather than structural change.

For organisations such as Game Devs of Color, accepting money can still advance the mission even when a donor is motivated partly by publicity. The organisation aims to expand the creative power of people of colour in games, but that work requires sustained access to funding, mentorship and professional relationships.

Small says corporate decision-making is often organised around quarterly results. That encourages businesses to support a cause when it is prominent, then withdraw when attention moves elsewhere. A one-off donation cannot change the everyday material circumstances facing Black communities or guarantee a career in games.

Access to capital is particularly important. Mentorship and connections matter, but money often determines whether a developer can turn an idea into a finished project. The industry’s creative ambitions therefore sit uneasily beside a business model focused on extracting revenue as quickly as possible.

This tension became more visible as support for inclusion weakened and online hostility grew. Small describes a renewed wave of racist, sexist and homophobic harassment, including misinformation aimed at developers of colour, women and queer people. Friends and colleagues have locked down their social media accounts or lost work after comments were taken out of context.

Representation cannot survive mass layoffs

The retreat from public commitments happened alongside an industry-wide employment crisis. Layoffs and studio closures became routine, driven by over-expansion during the pandemic, changing market conditions, inflation, tariffs, reduced investment and the adoption of artificial intelligence. Black workers are historically more exposed when economies deteriorate, and game development has not escaped that pattern.

Jarory De Jesus says layoffs remove more than individual jobs. When experienced people who act as cultural anchors disappear, remaining teams can become more homogeneous, cautious and less organic. He also expects many talented developers who were dismissed to form smaller independent and AA studios.

Kat Barkwell, a programmer who worked at BioWare and EA, saw the contradictions from inside the business. Before moving to Edmonton, Alberta, her father warned her about the city’s systemic racism, even though it is also a major development hub. At BioWare, where she worked on Anthem, she left a predominantly white women’s employee resource group and later found a better fit in the BEAT, or Black EA Team, group.

Remote work eventually gave Barkwell her first Black manager. Earlier managers had advised her to keep her head down and let her work speak for itself. Her new manager explained that, as a quiet and introverted programmer, she needed to communicate her contributions clearly or risk being perceived as lazy. That practical advice made a substantial difference to her career.

After 2020, EA leadership was initially receptive to proposals supporting Game Devs of Color and local groups assisting marginalised creators. Barkwell contributed to those efforts, but later requests for donations went unanswered. Layoffs and the apparent expiry of corporate racial solidarity contributed to her decision to leave AAA development after working on 2025’s Skate., seeking a healthier workplace and greater peace of mind.

Black developers are still underrepresented

Tanya DePass, founder of I Need Diverse Games, says 2020 briefly created a “golden era” in which she could secure contracts, share opportunities and refer other developers. The later contraction brought cancelled projects and studio closures, including the closure of Cliffhanger Games and its Black Panther project, and the shutdown of Monolith Productions and its Wonder Woman game.

When games featuring Black or female protagonists are cancelled, online reactionaries can wrongly treat those decisions as proof that audiences reject diverse characters. DePass argues that this loud minority should not dictate creative or commercial decisions. Requiring workers to relocate to expensive cities for unstable jobs also makes little sense, particularly when biased recruitment technology can make it harder for Black applicants to find work.

The 2026 GDC State of the Game Industry data cited in these discussions describes a workforce that is 64 per cent men and 67 per cent white, with 30 per cent of respondents identifying as queer. Most workers are aged between 25 and 44, while Black developers represent 5 per cent of the reported total. DePass notes that this figure has risen only two percentage points in 12 years, from 3 per cent.

Video Game Investment

Progress does exist. DePass points to the Black in Gaming Awards and other community efforts, but events such as GDC remain expensive. Tickets, flights and accommodation can place professional networking beyond the reach of working-class developers, especially when conferences are held in costly American cities.

Del Walker, a senior character artist, describes another pressure: the cost of making games is rising at the same time as the cost of living. California, where much of the United States games industry operates, is especially expensive. Moving the industry from California to Atlanta or South Carolina would not solve the underlying problem if each new hub becomes unaffordable in turn.

Walker believes the pandemic distorted company decisions. In 2020, publishers benefited from a major revenue surge while people were confined at home. Businesses expanded payrolls, investment and mergers beyond sustainable levels, often to satisfy shareholder expectations. When that temporary growth receded, employees paid the price.

He also argues that job advertisements increasingly expect one person to cover an unreasonable number of disciplines. The result is a demand for generalists with specialist-level skills, while Black workers remain disproportionately vulnerable during downturns.

Who gets to make diverse games?

Sweet Baby co-founder and chief executive Kim Belair observed how studios responded to the 2020 “racial reckoning”. Some companies did not want to be left behind, and money began to flow towards initiatives that appeared supportive. For some people that created opportunities; for others, Belair says, it was misleading or deceptive.

Portfolio reviews and advice can help individual writers, but they do not fix an industry whose barriers are racist, sexist and homophobic. Treating marginalised developers as if they simply need better portfolios places responsibility on workers rather than on the institutions controlling hiring and promotion.

Belair recalls working with Sony Santa Monica on God of War Ragnarök after racist criticism followed the reveal of Angrboda, a young Black girl. The studio sought advice about the relationship between artistic decisions and politics. That kind of engagement is valuable, but it must be matched by a willingness to defend creative choices publicly.

Belair says corporate support for diverse games had largely expired by 2023. Companies wanted the commercial benefit of appearing progressive, but often stayed silent when reactionary players attacked those same games. Her own Black-led consultancy became the target of a major harassment campaign, yet the hostility did not prevent the company from continuing to find work because clients recognised the quality of its output.

She also observed that police are among the most protected institutions in game storytelling. Writers may be asked to include a “good” officer whenever a corrupt or abusive one appears, even though police violence and the history of policing remain central parts of real-world racial politics.

Where are the Black auteurs?

Narrative designer Evan Narcisse questions whether the industry has created the conditions for Black creative leaders to build lasting careers. More diverse characters on screen do not answer who is writing, directing and shaping those characters behind the scenes.

Narcisse argues that games have yet to produce a Black auteur with the cultural standing of filmmakers such as Spike Lee or Ryan Coogler. He believes the career path has historically demanded a form of social and cultural alignment that excludes too many people.

He has often been the only Black narrative designer on a project. At Brass Lion Entertainment, which is developing Wu-Tang: Rise of the Deceiver, he became a senior writer for the first time. The studio’s stated purpose is to expand opportunities for Black, Brown and other marginalised developers.

Narcisse also points to Nyamakop’s Relooted as an example of a game that can express cultural values rather than simply reproduce stereotypes. He worries, however, that creative careers can disappear within five, seven or 10 years, as happened to several Black filmmakers whose work inspired him.

Community work continues after the headlines

Justin Woodward, director and career developer at Black Voices in Gaming, says the organisation’s central mission has not changed: create opportunities for developers to secure funding through grants, publishers, investors and partners.

The work has become harder because of layoffs, weaker investment and political hostility. The United States does not offer the kind of government support for game development found in some other countries, while venture capital has shifted towards technology, artificial intelligence and the latest investment trend. Woodward describes venture capital as an old boys’ club that can be especially difficult for Black founders to enter.

Black Voices in Gaming’s showcase has become a regular part of the annual games calendar. Woodward also led the Black Game Developer Fund at Humble Bundle, which distributed US$1 million each year to Black game makers. The organisation helped support newer initiatives such as Destinee Cleveland’s Dames 4 Games, which promotes the visibility, careers and networking opportunities of women and femmes.

Woodward was not surprised when corporate funding for equity initiatives dried up. In his view, many programmes were never core to the businesses that created them. They were useful for publicity while the political and commercial climate favoured them, then became expendable when that climate changed.

Even so, he sees possibility in the current disruption. Layoffs are devastating, but they can also push experienced developers to form new teams and create a fresh wave of independent work. The challenge is ensuring that this creativity produces distinctive games rather than simply reproducing the safest commercial formulas.

A precarious career with little room to speak

Adanna Nedd, a developer and author of the Black Game Dev Survey, found that 66.1 per cent of respondents had either been directly affected by layoffs or knew someone who had been. The survey had a relatively small participant pool, but it illustrates how employment insecurity shapes everyday behaviour.

One anonymous developer said 2020 briefly felt like a period of possibility. Their work was recognised when a game launched, but acknowledgement of underrepresented contributors faded afterwards. With fewer jobs available, they now feel less able to challenge management and more pressure to perform a cheerful corporate persona while being careful not to be labelled aggressive.

Production costs and development times have also grown. A career in games may last around five years, and a developer can spend that entire period without shipping a title. Cancelled projects can leave experienced workers with little visible credit despite years of labour. The developer believes a central union could help protect people from arbitrary decisions and mass layoffs.

Ea Sports

Black people are talent, not a resource

The developers interviewed describe the industry’s relationship with Black professionals as cautious, distrustful and often transactional. Barkwell says the sector has little interest in meaningful change, although she hopes more developers will create their own studios and opportunities.

DePass wants Black developers to be recognised simply as developers, rather than constantly being introduced through racial, gender or sexuality labels. She points to Surgent Studios, founder Abubakar Salim and Tales of Kenzera: ZAU as examples of creators building work on their own terms.

For Belair, the relationship is contentious but can improve if every party is honest about the power being exercised. Narcisse describes a daily process of mutual support among Black creative professionals, who share advice, protect one another and try to make work that opens the door for others.

Walker sees low trust everywhere. He has watched people relocate between countries for a new role, only to be laid off within days. Positive performance reviews can also be followed by sudden redundancies. That instability makes it difficult for developers to experiment, challenge familiar ideas or speak openly about conditions at work.

There are still organisations and individuals supporting labour movements, Black creators, queer developers and other overlooked communities. Some developers have supported Palestinian solidarity and the BDS movement, while studios and creators offered assistance for abortion access after Roe v Wade was overturned. These efforts do not erase the industry’s contradictions, but they demonstrate that collective action is possible.

The work is not finished

The games industry continues to carry a history of labour disputes, military relationships and partnerships with defence contractors. It can celebrate culturally specific characters while protecting institutions such as policing from serious criticism. It can promote inclusion while allowing the people who create inclusive work to be harassed, underpaid or dismissed.

Those contradictions are not isolated mistakes. They are connected to a business culture built around constant growth, shareholder value and the treatment of workers as costs. A polished statement, a social media graphic or a single donation cannot substitute for stable employment, fair hiring, access to capital, union protection and genuine creative authority.

For the industry to change, representation must be measured by who has power behind the scenes, who receives opportunities and who can remain employed long enough to build a career. Black developers are not a marketing resource to be used during a crisis and discarded when the news cycle moves on.

Community groups, independent studios and individual creators continue to build alternatives. Their work offers a more credible path than corporate symbolism: sustained funding, shared knowledge, meaningful accountability and room for developers to tell stories shaped by their own experiences.

Games are made by people, and the conditions of production are inseparable from the wider world. The industry can either keep repeating its public commitments when convenient, or support the people whose talent, labour and creativity make those commitments meaningful.

For readers exploring the wider arcade and games landscape, RETROCADE’s arcade blog, arcade videos and arcade machine buying guide cover the technology, history and people behind the games we play.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *