RETROCADE RETROCADE
0
RETROCADE arcade machines, virtual pinball, racing simulator and parts banner

The 2026 Game Awards nominations have arrived, prompting the usual debate over which games received recognition and which were overlooked. With a jury of more than 100 outlets, no shortlist can reflect every genre, platform or player perspective. These are six of the most discussed omissions.

For more gaming news and industry discussion, visit the RETROCADE Arcade Blog.

Best Ongoing Game needs a wider field

The Best Ongoing Game category is intended to recognise live-service titles that delivered meaningful updates and expansions during the year. Its 2026 nominees are Arc Raiders, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, Final Fantasy XIV, Fortnite and No Man’s Sky.

Final Fantasy XIV, Fortnite and No Man’s Sky have appeared in the category repeatedly, which has led some players to question whether the nominations reflect the wider live-service landscape. World of Warcraft had three expansions, new Classic versions including an anniversary edition, and a new Forever version during the lifetime of Dawntrails, yet again missed out. Players have also pointed to RuneScape and Guild Wars 2 as ongoing games that rarely receive recognition.

Overwatch was another notable omission. Its 2026 reboot introduced a revised story and an unprecedented ten new heroes, but the hero shooter that once won Game of the Year is no longer receiving the same level of awards attention.

Marathon overlooked for Best Art Direction

Bungie’s extraction shooter has divided opinion, although it has developed a committed audience among players who connected with its style and systems. Even people who did not spend much time with it were surprised that Marathon missed Best Art Direction.

Players also argued that its audio deserved consideration. The criticism centres on the game’s distinctive visual identity, with supporters saying the artistic direction should be assessed separately from wider disagreements about the game itself.

Crimson Desert receives limited recognition

Pearl Abyss’ fantasy action RPG earned a nomination for Best Community Support, but nowhere else. Its complicated control scheme reportedly discouraged some players, while those who enjoyed the game often responded enthusiastically to its scope and action design.

That contrast has made the nomination list feel surprising to some fans. The game was not recognised in Best RPG, Best Action/Adventure or Game of the Year, despite supporters arguing that it belonged in conversations across those categories.

Fire Emblem: Fortune’s Weave falls short

Fire Emblem: Fortune’s Weave received just one nomination, in Best RPG. That result stands out because the previous two series entries, Fire Emblem: Three Houses and Fire Emblem Engage, were nominated in the Strategy category in their respective years.

Fans questioned the absence of nominations for Best Performance, Best Score and Soundtrack, Best Narrative and Best Sim/Strategy Game. The soundtrack was also singled out in comparisons with Mixtape, while some players felt the game’s tactical identity should have secured a place in the strategy category.

For readers interested in bringing classic strategy and action games home, RETROCADE’s arcade machines offer a dedicated way to build a home gaming setup.

Gears of War: E-Day misses Game of the Year

The Coalition’s prequel to the 2006 original was not completely ignored. Gears of War: E-Day earned nominations for Action Game, Innovation in Accessibility and Best Multiplayer.

However, sections of the Xbox community believed the game deserved consideration for Game of the Year, Best Art Direction and acting recognition for Marcus’s voice actor. The discussion was particularly strong among long-time fans of the series, who viewed the prequel as one of the year’s major releases. Xbox fans discussed the omissions on Reddit.

Street Fighter loses out to The Super Mario Galaxy Movie

The Best Adaptation category also generated controversy. Street Fighter was left out, while The Super Mario Galaxy Movie was nominated. That decision was especially striking to viewers who saw the Street Fighter film as a deliberately chaotic but memorable adaptation.

The omission also revived complaints about last year’s Best Adaptation result, when Sonic the Hedgehog 3 was not nominated and the award went to the second season of The Last of Us.

Which games did the nominations miss?

Awards shortlists will always leave strong releases outside the conversation, particularly when a single jury must compare very different games and formats. The 2026 nominations have already produced arguments around live-service support, art direction, strategy design, adaptation and overall achievement.

For more ways to enjoy games at home, explore RETROCADE’s bartop arcades and Arcade Machine Buying Guide.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *