
10 brilliant games overlooked for Game of the Year
The 2026 Game Awards nominations sparked plenty of debate. Grand Theft Auto 6 led the field with eight nominations, including Game of the Year, despite not yet being released. No independent game made the GOTY shortlist, leaving acclaimed titles such as Mina the Hollower and Big Walk outside the race. Major releases including Fire Emblem: Fortune’s Weave and Pokémon Pokopia were also absent from the top category.
That disappointment is familiar. The following games may have received recognition in other categories, but each missed a Game of the Year nomination. Some were competing against unusually strong releases, while others faced the disadvantages commonly experienced by indies, remakes, sequels and difficult games.

10. Dark Souls 3
Where to play: PlayStation 4, Windows PC and Xbox One
Dark Souls 3 provided a beautiful, melancholy conclusion to FromSoftware’s influential trilogy. Faster combat helped connect the established Dark Souls formula with Bloodborne and, later, Elden Ring. It was a confident demonstration of the studio’s command of the style it had helped define.
Despite its acclaim, the game received only a Best RPG nomination in 2016 and missed GOTY. The field included Overwatch, Doom and Inside, making it one of the year’s most competitive categories. Extremely challenging games can also struggle to reach a broad awards audience.
9. Outer Wilds
Where to play: Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Windows PC and Xbox One
Outer Wilds combines open-world exploration, adventure and puzzle design without making combat the centre of the experience. Curiosity and accumulated knowledge drive progress, while its tightly constructed story creates an unusually immersive journey.
The 2019 field was packed with contenders including Control, Death Stranding, Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice, Super Smash Bros. Ultimate, The Outer Worlds and the Resident Evil 2 remake. Disco Elysium, Fire Emblem: Three Houses and Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order also missed out. As an indie game that built its audience gradually through word of mouth, Outer Wilds was deserving but unlikely to break through.

8. NieR:Automata
Where to play: Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Windows PC and Xbox One
NieR:Automata brought Square Enix’s relatively obscure Drakengard spin-off universe to a much wider audience. Its existential narrative, multiple endings and seamless shifts between bullet-hell shooting, hack-and-slash combat and side-scrolling sections made it unlike almost anything else in the field.
It competed unsuccessfully against mainstream favourites including The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, Super Mario Odyssey and Horizon Zero Dawn. Although Automata became a critical and commercial breakthrough, its niche origins, philosophical themes and numerous endings may have made it less accessible to voters.
7. Ghost of Yotei
Where to play: PlayStation 5
Ghost of Yotei, the follow-up to 2020 GOTY nominee Ghost of Tsushima, combines polished action with a strongly cinematic presentation. Its influences include Takashi Miike’s 13 Assassins and Shinichiro Watanabe’s Cowboy Bebop, while one game mode draws inspiration from Akira Kurosawa’s Seven Samurai. The visual ambition never comes at the expense of fluid, intense gameplay.
In 2025 it earned seven nominations, including Best Direction, Narrative, Audio Design and Action/Adventure Game, yet missed GOTY. The result seemed especially surprising given its recognition in so many adjacent categories. A likely explanation was sequel fatigue: some critics felt it did not separate itself enough from Ghost of Tsushima.

6. Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze
Where to play: Wii U and Nintendo Switch
Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze is a precise platforming showcase. Its themed stages and purposeful mechanics reward momentum, letting players link rolls, jumps and carefully timed landings. David Wise’s soundtrack adds another memorable layer.
Released in 2014, the first year of the Game Awards, it faced Bayonetta 2, Dark Souls 2 and Dragon Age: Inquisition. Its focus also did not match the tone favoured by the early awards. Launching on the commercially unsuccessful Wii U further limited its reach, even though the later Switch version introduced it to a much larger platforming audience.
5. Hollow Knight
Where to play: Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Windows PC and Xbox One
Hollow Knight places players in the vast underground kingdom of Hallownest, offering little guidance while gradually revealing its secrets, history and tragedy. Its difficult combat and exploration have helped it become widely regarded as one of the strongest games of the 2010s.
At launch, however, it lacked the publicity enjoyed by major releases. Like many independent games, it grew slowly through player recommendations rather than an immediate blockbuster campaign. The series later received indirect awards attention when Hollow Knight: Silksong was nominated, although it lost to Clair Obscur: Expedition 33.

4. Silent Hill 2
Where to play: PlayStation 4, Windows PC and Xbox One
Konami and Bloober Team’s Silent Hill 2 revisited the psychological horror classic from 2001. The remake preserved its oppressive atmosphere and emotional weight while modernising the survival-horror systems. Updated visuals and stronger performances helped make its fear and tragedy accessible to a new generation.
Horror has historically found the GOTY race difficult, although major releases such as Resident Evil 2 have broken through. The category’s only horror-adjacent winner was The Last of Us Part II in 2020. Silent Hill 2 also faced the usual awards disadvantage of being a remake: remakes are rarely nominated and have never won GOTY.
3. Fire Emblem: Three Houses
Where to play: Nintendo Switch
Fire Emblem: Three Houses became the best-selling mainline entry in the series, helping establish Fire Emblem as a Nintendo flagship. Its branching routes deliver a sprawling story of war, love and betrayal, while disagreements about its characters and choices have continued among fans for years.
Like Outer Wilds, it arrived during the crowded 2019 awards season. Its presentation could be rough, including its much-criticised fruit textures, and the monastery hub becomes repetitive for some players. Completing the full story also requires four campaigns. Those shortcomings help explain the omission, even if the snub remains frustrating.

2. Yakuza 0
Where to play: Nintendo Switch 2, PlayStation 4, Windows PC and Xbox One
Yakuza 0 balances two protagonists, an intense crime drama, exaggerated combat and broad comedy without losing the series’ distinctive style. It tells an emotional story about two defining characters while leaving room for the eccentric side content that became a hallmark of the franchise.
Its overseas release in 2016 was slowed by the language barrier and the lack of an English dub. A dub eventually arrived with the 2025 Director’s Cut. When Yakuza 0 reached Steam in 2018, its sales nearly doubled, helping make it the best-selling game in the series. Its memes and growing Western audience arrived gradually, rather than as an overnight awards phenomenon.
1. Mina the Hollower
Where to play: Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 5, Windows PC and Xbox Series X
Mina the Hollower is the clearest omission from this year’s list. Its densely designed stages represent an enormous development effort, matching the ambition of many large-budget releases. The result is a challenging adventure that draws on early The Legend of Zelda games, Game Boy Color design and Gothic horror.
It did receive a Best Indie Game nomination, but missed a GOTY field that contained no independent titles. Despite strong critical reception, the voting appeared to favour mainstream blockbusters. Its considerable difficulty may also have limited its appeal beyond dedicated players.


Great games are not defined by awards
A GOTY shortlist reflects a particular year, voting body and set of expectations. These ten releases show how platform reach, genre conventions, sequel fatigue, remake status, difficulty and marketing momentum can influence recognition. For more gaming coverage, browse the RETROCADE arcade blog, explore the arcade video collection or use the arcade machine buying guide.


Leave a Reply