Big Walk AI controversy puts GOTY season under the microscope
Big Walk entered 2026 as one of the year’s best-reviewed games and a strong Game of the Year contender. That position is now uncertain after developer House House disclosed its use of generative AI during development, prompting a wider discussion about where the games industry should draw the line.


IGF jurors take a firm position
A group of 19 Independent Games Festival jurors, including Immortality director Sam Barlow and Friends at the Table host Austin Walker, said they would not vote for any game that used generative AI tools in any capacity. Their position includes programming and other technical work, not only art, writing, music or voice performance. You can read the published statement.
Barlow said the jury’s discussions about AI are always lively, but that this year’s conversation was especially intense. The reason became clearer when House House voluntarily disclosed to the festival that Big Walk had used generative AI tools during development.

In a follow-up statement, Barlow clarified that Big Walk was a difficult edge case rather than the sole reason for the discussion. The broader concern was the growing number of games using generative AI.
What House House disclosed
House House said that well under 0.1% of Big Walk’s code had any connection to generative AI. The tools were used to work through difficult technical problems and bugs, rather than to create the game’s wider creative content.
The Melbourne studio said large language models produced a baseline that its team then modified into game code. One example involved a lighting problem during the final stage of development and amounted to about 10 lines of code. House House has published further details in the developer’s FAQ.

For the 19 jurors, however, the small scale of the use does not change the principle. A firm rule only works if it applies when the boundary is crossed.
Why coding is part of the argument
The jurors cited the technology’s documented effects on the economy, employment, the environment and the reliability of online information. They also argued that generative AI is not an unavoidable part of game development. As independent developers, they said they have an opportunity to take a position that people at larger companies may not be able to express as freely.
Including code in that position is significant. Public criticism of generative AI in games usually focuses on creative disciplines, while programming is often treated as an exception. This stance instead recognises coding as part of the creative work of making a game. Developers responding to Walker’s post thanked the jurors for making that case publicly.

Awards implications remain unclear
The disclosure has divided the gaming community. Some players see the lack of an announcement at launch as the central issue and question what else might not have been disclosed. Steam requires developers to identify generative AI use, although that requirement does not specifically cover code or chatbot assistance.
Others view Big Walk as a relatively restrained example. They argue that excluding a game over roughly 10 lines of AI-assisted code could create an impractical standard, while House House’s willingness to explain the process suggests that the studio is open to changing its approach. The studio has also previously pledged 1% of its profits to organisations helping Indigenous communities with rent, following the release of Untitled Goose Game in 2020.
The controversy could affect Big Walk during awards season, even though the public statement came from fewer than 20 IGF jurors. Its arguments have spread through social and traditional media, potentially influencing other voters or making them hesitate.
The effect on The Game Awards is harder to predict. Before the controversy, Big Walk was considered very likely to receive a Game of the Year nomination. Independent games already face a difficult path in that category, and the debate adds another obstacle.
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 demonstrated in 2025 that an independent game can break into the mainstream and dominate awards. However, its Game of the Year prize at the separate Indie Game Awards was later withdrawn because of AI inclusion. That distinction may be relevant to Big Walk’s prospects.
A broader industry fault line
The dispute arrives after years of uncertainty about generative AI in game development. Developers ranging from the creator of The Last of Us to the studio behind the Wendy’s JRPG have publicly rejected AI in every part of development. Others have adopted the tools despite criticism, including Embark Studios with The Finals in 2023 and Arc Raiders in 2025. Epic Games chief executive Tim Sweeney has also been notably enthusiastic about large language models.

For large parts of the gaming audience, AI remains a particularly sensitive subject. Developers that reveal its use have often faced public pressure and issued apologies. House House has now joined that group.
“Big Walk was developed without an internal AI usage policy in place, and we consider that lack of policy a failure,” House House said. “We will work to have a more comprehensive policy going forwards.”
That admission gives the studio a clearer framework for future projects, but the uncertainty is not solely a small Melbourne developer’s responsibility. Generative AI tools have been publicly available for almost five years, while governments have yet to establish widely accepted rules about permissible use. Until regulation and industry standards become clearer, similar disputes are likely to continue.




For more coverage of the games business, visit the RETROCADE Arcade Blog. Readers exploring how modern games translate to dedicated hardware can also browse the Arcade Machine Buying Guide or view the latest arcade machines.


Leave a Reply