Matt Mercer’s Best D&D Advice: Failure Helps You Improve
Matthew Mercer is one of the world’s best-known Dungeon Masters. Through Critical Role, the multimedia entertainment company he co-founded, he has helped shape how many players approach tabletop role-playing games.
Mercer has also consistently supported new Dungeon Masters, sharing practical advice and appearing on official Dungeons & Dragons programming to help others build their skills.


His guidance covers everything from preparation to improvisation, but one idea stands out for players and DMs alike: becoming better at the game requires accepting that things will sometimes go wrong.
That lesson also applies to anyone creating a shared gaming space, whether they are organising a tabletop group or choosing an arcade machine for friends and family.
What is Matt Mercer’s most useful D&D quote?
In a conversation published in January 2026, Mercer spoke with Brennan Lee Mulligan about Dungeons & Dragons, their careers and the work involved in running tabletop sessions. Mulligan is known for his role as Dungeon Master on Dimension 20, while Mercer leads games for Critical Role.
When Mulligan asked Mercer about his approach to preparing a session, Mercer offered a concise answer:
“Like many things, it comes with experience, and sometimes you have to fail to learn better.”
It is straightforward advice, but it captures why tabletop role-playing works so well. A session is not a performance that must follow a perfect plan. It is a collaborative story shaped by decisions, surprises and the willingness to adapt.

Why failure matters in D&D
Failure is often treated as something to avoid, yet it can be one of the most useful parts of a campaign. A failed roll, an unexpected decision or an encounter that does not unfold as planned can reveal what needs to change.
For a Dungeon Master, that might mean learning when preparation has become too rigid. For a player, it can mean discovering that an imperfect choice still creates an entertaining moment for the whole group.

The pressure to make every decision perfectly can be surprisingly damaging. A DM may worry constantly about whether the group is having fun or try to force the adventure back towards a planned outcome. Players can become so concerned about choosing the correct action that the game loses momentum.
Mercer’s point is not that preparation is unimportant. Instead, preparation should leave room for the people at the table to influence what happens next. The best plans provide direction without removing everyone’s freedom to experiment.
A lesson for new Dungeon Masters
Many first-time DMs prepare scenes as if the players will follow a fixed sequence. When the group takes an unexpected route, it can feel as though the campaign has gone off course.
That reaction is understandable, but trying to force the story back into its original shape can create unfair rulings and unnecessary tension. Pausing to acknowledge the surprise, ask questions and improvise a new path is often more effective.

Admitting that a ruling or idea did not work is not a sign that the DM has failed the group. It can build trust. Players are usually more willing to explore a world when they know the person running it can adjust openly rather than pretending every outcome was planned.
The same principle applies to the wider hobby. A new DIY arcade project may need revisions, and a tabletop campaign may take an unexpected turn. Improvement comes from noticing what happened and using that experience next time.
Enjoyment matters more than perfection
Whether you are behind the screen or rolling the dice, perfection can distract from the reason everyone gathered. The goal is not to produce flawless encounters or guarantee the best possible outcome for every character.
The goal is to create memorable moments together. Sometimes those moments come from clever plans, and sometimes they come from spectacular mistakes that the group remembers long after the session ends.
Mercer’s advice is therefore valuable because it is practical rather than grandiose: experience teaches you, and failure is part of gaining that experience. Give yourself permission to make mistakes, learn from them and keep the story moving.
For more ideas about building a shared gaming setup, explore RETROCADE’s arcade machine buying guide, browse compact bartop arcades or read the latest stories in the Arcade Blog.





Leave a Reply