RETROCADE RETROCADE
0
RETROCADE arcade machines, virtual pinball, racing simulator and parts banner

Dungeon Crawler Carl Books Ranked by Goodreads Score

4

Matt Dinniman’s Dungeon Crawler Carl combines LitRPG mechanics, apocalyptic horror, reality television satire and dungeon-crawling fantasy. Carl is forced into an alien-run game show, where survival depends on defeating monsters, exploiting game systems and enduring a talking cat with an enormous personality.

Under the gore and comedy is a story about people resisting a system that turns suffering into entertainment. The series shares some survival-story DNA with The Maze Runner and The Hunger Games, but its cosmic game-show structure gives it a distinctive identity.

All eight published books sit above 4.3 stars on Goodreads, so this is a comparison of very well-liked novels rather than a search for a failure. With the ninth book expected next year, and described by Dinniman as the first half of a planned two-part conclusion, here is how the existing books rank by their Goodreads scores.

Readers interested in game-inspired entertainment can also explore RETROCADE’s arcade blog, browse arcade machines or use the arcade machine buying guide.

8. The Dungeon Anarchist’s Cookbook

Book 3 The Dungeon Anarchist's Cookbook

Goodreads Rating: 4.37

The third book sends Carl and Princess Donut into the Fourth Floor’s Iron Tangle, a hostile underground rail network filled with stations, trains and monsters. Its complicated layout makes navigation as important as combat, creating one of the series’ most mechanically demanding challenges.

The setting can test a reader’s patience, but the story remains inventive. Carl and Donut become increasingly desperate, while cooperation between crawlers begins to matter more. Its comparatively modest score reflects the divisive maze-like structure rather than a shortage of ideas.

7. Dungeon Crawler Carl

Book 1 Dungeon Crawler Carl

Goodreads Rating: 4.42

The opening novel establishes the series’ central nightmare: an apocalyptic event turns Earth into a lethal televised competition. Carl enters the dungeon with his ex-girlfriend’s cat, Princess Donut, and the unlikely pair must survive the first two floors.

This debut is simpler than the later entries, before the mythology, cast and rules become considerably larger. Its greatest strength is the relationship between the practical Carl and the opinionated Donut. The blend of gruesome creatures, game mechanics and television satire provides a strong foundation, even if later books are more ambitious.

6. Carl’s Doomsday Scenario

Book 2 Carl's Doomsday Scenario

Goodreads Rating: 4.46

The sequel moves the action to the open wilderness of the Third Floor, known as Over-the-Land. Goblin sappers, siege engines and bizarre holiday-themed bosses force Carl to turn almost anything in his inventory into a weapon or trap.

As the game show expands, its cosmic corporate sponsors become more visible and more disturbing, manipulating the rules to increase audience engagement while treating human lives as expendable. Carl’s resourcefulness and Donut’s transformation from pampered house cat into a scene-stealing diva remain central to the appeal.

5. The Gate of the Feral Gods

Book 4 The Gate of the Feral Gods

Goodreads Rating: 4.52

On the Fifth Floor, survival requires more than defeating whatever is in front of Carl and Donut. The challenges become sprawling and interconnected, demanding creative problem-solving alongside brute force.

The growing network of allies and fellow crawlers gives the story greater emotional reach. Complex deity-favour systems and punishing environmental hazards are not just decorative rules; they have meaningful consequences for the plot. A 4.52 rating reflects the series’ expanding world and stronger ensemble cast.

4. A Parade of Horribles

Book 8 A Parade of Horribles

Goodreads Rating: 4.60

The eighth and latest book takes Carl and Donut to the Tenth Floor, Sheol, where the dungeon crawl develops into a galactic war. Carl must deal with troop movements, political betrayals and flesh-warping curses that threaten his sanity, while the conflict grows into a revolution against the Syndicate.

The scale is now far beyond a conventional dungeon run, with consequences reaching across the galaxy. Carl’s deteriorating mental state, Donut’s emotional development and the collapse of the system carry as much weight as the battles. Its 4.60 score is a slight statistical dip beside the series’ highest-rated books, but it remains a major achievement.

3. The Eye of the Bedlam Bride

Book 6 The Eye of the Bedlam Bride

Goodreads Rating: 4.62

The sixth novel shows that the dungeon’s greatest dangers are not always the creatures with the sharpest claws. Carl and Donut face another elaborate trial as the mythology deepens and the consequences of the crawl become increasingly unsettling.

Dinniman continues to balance grotesque humour with genuine tension. The mechanics and expanding cast ask more of the reader, but the result is a more emotionally loaded adventure than the early books. Its 4.62 rating reflects that achievement, even if its complexity can make it less immediately accessible than the series’ most streamlined entries.

2. This Inevitable Ruin

Goodreads Rating: 4.66

Book 7 This Inevitable Ruin

The seventh book pushes the overarching conflict towards a new level of intensity, drawing on the alliances, rivalries and knowledge accumulated throughout Carl and Donut’s ordeal.

Its tactical combat, grotesque comedy and cosmic absurdity all serve a darker story about human survival inside an oppressive system built to monetise suffering. As the rules begin to fail and the rebellion reaches beyond the dungeon, every victory comes with a severe cost. The 4.66 score places it just below the series leader.

1. The Butcher’s Masquerade

Goodreads Rating: 4.67

Book 5 The Butcher's Masquerade

Goodreads readers currently place the fifth book at the top. Carl and Princess Donut enter the Ninth Floor’s Celestial Masquerade, a warlord-style battleground where powerful galactic sponsors and hunters enter the zone to kill crawlers for sport.

Faction warfare, the horrific Hunting Parties and the loss of long-standing allies push the emotional stakes higher than before. Carl’s desperate tactics reach a new peak, leading to a major climax that shows the game show’s elite audience may have created a threat it can no longer control.

After four books of refining its mix of game-inspired puzzles, outrageous comedy and emotional investment, the series brings those elements together with unusual confidence here. The supporting cast adds depth to the chaos, while the 4.67 rating gives The Butcher’s Masquerade the narrowest victory in the ranking.

For a more hands-on take on games built around rules, challenges and spectacle, browse RETROCADE’s compact bartop arcades or investigate DIY arcade kits.

The Wolf Among Us Remastered artwork
A player character in their garden in Moonlight Peaks
critical role hed
phantom blade zero characters holds blade

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *