Matt Mercer’s reminder that every D&D table belongs to its players
Critical Role has spent more than a decade showing audiences what can happen when experienced performers, strong character work and improvisational Dungeons & Dragons come together. Its cast of professional voice actors has built a loyal following through memorable adventures, dramatic turns and plenty of unscripted chaos.
That format has also produced some unforgettable lines. Few, however, capture the spirit of the show better than a quiet response Matthew Mercer gave during Campaign 3: “It’s our game to have fun.”
For readers discovering actual-play campaigns, the Critical Role overview offers useful background on the series.
The moment behind the quote
In episode 42 of Campaign 3, the group reaches Yios, a lake-top city with a gambling venue full of dice-based games. The cast becomes absorbed in the diversions instead of immediately pursuing its original objective.
Laura Bailey apologises to the table and the audience for spending so much time on the gambling games. Mercer makes it clear that an apology is unnecessary, then addresses viewers at home.
“It’s our game to have fun. Glad you guys are here to watch, but we’re going to play our game, like we always have.”
The line lacks the theatrical impact of Mercer’s famous “How do you want to do this?” but its meaning is just as important. An actual-play show may have a large audience, yet the people at the table still have the right to decide where their story goes.
Why the quote matters to D&D fans
Actual-play D&D is unusual because the audience sees the story develop through choices made by the players and Game Master. Those decisions can be entertaining, frustrating or surprising, but they remain part of the group’s shared game rather than a service designed to satisfy every viewer.
That distinction becomes harder to maintain as a campaign grows. Critical Role has attracted a devoted fanbase, and enthusiasm brings conversation, community and powerful word-of-mouth promotion. It can also create a sense of ownership among viewers who believe the cast should play according to their preferred interpretation of the rules.
Rules, house decisions and creative freedom
Some fans objected when Mercer made resurrection more difficult early in Campaign 2, arguing that the change did not follow the rules as written. Others criticised Marisha Ray’s Campaign 3 character, Laudna, for not strictly matching the established traits of her Hollowed One lineage after the character’s features were given a more individual interpretation.
Criticism itself is not the problem. Viewers can reasonably discuss the choices made by the cast. The concern begins when discussion turns into entitlement: the assumption that watching a campaign gives an audience the authority to dictate how it must be played.
The same tension can appear in format decisions. The campaign’s West Marches approach has been questioned by some viewers who feel it reduces the narrative potential available to certain characters. That is a valid response as an opinion, but it does not make the audience the final decision-maker.
A table’s story is not a public vote
Critical Role’s worlds have expanded well beyond the original table. Amazon helps produce animated adaptations of the campaigns, including The Legend of Vox Machina and The Mighty Nein, while CEO Travis Willingham has stated that outside involvement has not changed how the games themselves are made.
Millions of people may watch the campaigns, and creators including Mercer and Brennan Lee Mulligan have helped shape Exandria and Aramán. Even so, viewers have limited influence over the story once the players and Game Master begin making decisions.
That is the larger lesson behind Mercer’s response. A campaign can welcome an audience without surrendering its creative control. The players are not performing a rules demonstration or taking instructions from social media; they are sitting down to play their own game.
For anyone running a home campaign, the principle applies just as clearly. Whether the table uses strict rules, house rules, unusual character concepts or a deliberately chaotic structure, the group should decide what makes the game enjoyable. A guide to choosing an arcade machine may not settle a D&D rules debate, but the same idea carries across hobbies: the people taking part should have the final say in how they enjoy it.
The best D&D slogan is simple
“It’s our game to have fun” works because it is both a defence of creative freedom and a straightforward description of what tabletop role-playing is meant to be. Fans can watch, discuss and disagree, but they cannot replace the people actually making the decisions at the table.
That makes Mercer’s short remark more than a response to one apology in one episode. It is a useful slogan for every D&D group: listen to feedback when it helps, ignore pressure when it harms the session, and remember that the game belongs first to the people playing it.
For more hobby and gaming features, explore RETROCADE’s arcade blog, browse arcade machines, or consider a DIY arcade kit.
Leave a Reply