World of Warcraft: Forever is steering players towards open-world adventures, but reduced dungeon experience rewards are making one of the game’s core group activities increasingly difficult to justify.
Why players are avoiding dungeons
Dungeons traditionally introduce players to organised group play while combining quest progress, equipment, currency and experience. With nine new dungeons included in Forever, they appeared set to become an important part of the levelling journey.
Instead, community reports suggest that dungeon enemies and bosses can provide surprisingly little experience. In some cases, players say that ordinary enemies in the open world offer better returns than creatures inside an instance. One discussion claims that boss XP is the same as mob XP.
That creates a poor trade-off. Forming a party, travelling to the entrance and completing a dungeon can take considerable time, while the final reward may amount to limited experience and perhaps one useful item. For players focused on efficient progression, open-world questing is becoming the more attractive choice.
How the XP changes developed
During the beta, the first major adjustment reduced experience from dungeon creatures and increased the rewards from dungeon quests. The apparent goal was to make each instance worthwhile for its story and equipment without allowing players to repeatedly run one dungeon as a fast levelling method.
That balance did not last. Dungeon quest experience appeared generous enough for players to advance rapidly by concentrating on instance objectives, prompting another change in October. The later reduction to dungeon quest XP meant that both major sources of dungeon experience were now significantly lower than many players remembered from the original game.
The initial changes are detailed in a report covering noticeable changes, while a later update explains how dungeon quest XP was reduced again.
A worse deal for ordinary dungeon runs
The problem affects more than players trying to optimise every level. A normal group may spend an hour or two finding the right roles, coordinating travel and clearing an instance, only to receive modest progression at the end. That feels especially frustrating when a quest chain requires the party to return more than once.
Low creature XP can also change party behaviour. When killing enemies contributes little to levelling, players have a stronger incentive to rush from objective to objective rather than explore, clear optional areas or help every member complete their tasks. One community post describes dungeons as miserable because everyone is focused on rushing quests.
Repeated visits are particularly awkward in Wailing Caverns, where several quests can require the same dungeon. A separate discussion questions the value of repeating Wailing Caverns when dungeon kills provide so little XP.
Layering complicates the open-world solution
Encouraging players to spend more time in the world is a reasonable design objective, but weakening dungeons does not automatically produce a healthier social experience. Some players say the new layering system places them in separate versions of the same zone, making it harder to encounter others and form groups.
The effect is not consistent everywhere. Mulgore and the Barrens can still feel crowded, yet reports of players struggling to find companions suggest that the wider group-building systems also need attention. One discussion describes a friend declining a dungeon run, while another player says an open-world enemy several levels below their character awarded more XP than a dungeon mob.
What could improve the balance?
Forever is not built around the instant, automated dungeon routine associated with newer versions of the game. Players still need to meet, organise a party and travel to the instance. That preparation is part of the classic-style experience, but it needs to lead to a reward that feels proportionate to the effort.
Restoring some creature experience, revisiting dungeon quest rewards or adding stronger completion incentives could all help. The eventual answer does not necessarily need to recreate the old system exactly, but the current balance appears to be pushing players away from content designed to support both the game’s stories and its social play.
Complaints are appearing across community discussions, forums and in-game chat, so further tuning seems likely. Until then, players who value efficient levelling may continue choosing open-world quests, even when a dungeon is the natural next step in their character’s story.
For more coverage of gaming news, visit the RETROCADE Arcade Blog. Readers exploring how games bring people together can also browse the arcade videos collection or explore arcade machines for social play.



Leave a Reply